top of page

Handwriting Instruction Programs, Compared: Four Letter Orders

Writer: Andrea Chernin
Andrea Chernin
Nov 11
21 min read

The short version


If you have ever picked up two handwriting programs and tried to work out which one a student should be on, you have probably noticed something awkward: they do not disagree about method. They disagree about the alphabet.


Not about the letters, obviously. About the order.


One program teaches the capitals first and groups them by where the pencil starts. Another pairs every lowercase letter with its capital and works through a sequence that begins with l. A third sorts the letters by the shape of the stroke and treats qu as a single unit. A fourth declines the whole problem by teaching one alphabet that serves as both print and cursive.


All four publish their sequence. None of them agrees with any other. And the federal practice guide that rates handwriting instruction as worth doing specifies no order at all, uses the word legibility zero times in nearly fifty thousand words, and says in print that the curriculum matters less than the outcome.


That is the comparison this post makes. Not which handwriting program works — the evidence does not support that question in the form practitioners usually ask it. What each one actually teaches, in what order, and against what definition of success.

What this post is not


This site already has a post on dysgraphia and writing intervention tools, and that one does a different job. It sorts the products into four categories, reports what each publisher claims, covers the evidence on whether handwriting is a motor problem you can drill away, and compares the assessment instruments you would use to decide a student needs transcription work at all.


It also carries the correction that matters most in this area, with three independent sources behind it, and this post does not restate it. If you have not read that section, read it there.


This post picks up where that one stops. It goes inside the programs, to the scope and sequence, and compares the instructional content rather than the marketing claim. Those are genuinely different questions, and the second one is almost entirely unwritten.


A note on scope before we start. Nothing here is a recommendation that any program works, or works better than another. Where a claim is attached to a source, the source is named and linked. Where a publisher does not publish something, that is reported as an absence in that document and nothing more.

Four programs, four published letter orders


Here is the comparison in one place. Each sequence below comes from the publisher's own document, linked in the section that follows.


  • Handwriting Without Tears teaches capitals before lowercase. Capitals in three groups, by starting point. Lowercase in five groups, by stroke family.

  • Zaner-Bloser teaches each lowercase letter alongside its capital, one pair at a time, in a single twenty-six-step sequence — and uses a completely different structure for cursive.

  • Logic of English teaches all lowercase before all uppercase, sorted into four named stroke groups.

  • Getty-Dubay Italic teaches one letterform that serves both scripts, so the print-to-cursive transition largely does not exist.


The first letter taught differs in every case. So does the logic of the grouping. So does the vocabulary used to name the strokes. A practitioner who learned one of these cannot read another's sequence without a translation key, and no translation key exists.


Four publishers, four orders, four stroke vocabularies with no shared terms. The disagreement is not at the level of philosophy. It is at the level of which letter comes second.

Handwriting Without Tears: capitals first, grouped by where the pencil starts


Learning Without Tears publishes its print teaching order as a standalone document. The teaching order sheet and the matching letter group posters between them give the full structure, and the group names are the publisher's own.


Capitals come first, in three groups:


  • Frog Jump Capitals — F, E, D, P, B, R, N, M

  • Starting Corner Capitals — H, K, L, U, V, W, X, Y, Z

  • Center Starting Capitals — C, O, Q, S, A, I, T, J, with G


Lowercase follows, in five groups. The first group is the letters that look like their capitals at a smaller size, plus t: c, o, s, v, w, t. Then the Magic c Letters — a, d, g — which are built from the c the student already owns.


Then the Transition Group: u, i, e, l, k, y, j. Then the Diver Letters: p, r, n, m, h, b. Then a final group of f, q, x, z.


One honest wrinkle worth naming. The two publisher documents list the Center Starting group's members in different internal orders — the teaching order sheet runs C, O, Q, S, A, I, T, J and the poster runs S, A, I, T, J, C, O, Q. The group membership agrees across both. The within-group order does not, so treat the group as the unit and not the sequence inside it.


The organising principle is motor, and it is explicit in the group names. Letters are collected by where the stroke begins and how it moves, not by frequency, not by phonics, and not by shape similarity to anything a student will read.

Zaner-Bloser: each lowercase letter with its capital, and a different plan for cursive


Zaner-Bloser publishes substantial teacher edition samples. The Grade 1 sample carries the full table of contents, which is the scope and sequence in all but name.


Strokes are taught before any letter: Vertical Line, Horizontal Line, Backward Circle Lines, Forward Circle Lines, Diagonal Lines. Then numerals. Then letters, each lowercase introduced with its capital, in this order:


l, i, t, q, o, a, u, d, s, b, p, c, e, r, f, n, m, h, g, j, v, y, w, x, k, z


Compare that with the Handwriting Without Tears order and the scale of the disagreement is clear. Zaner-Bloser's first letter is l. Handwriting Without Tears does not reach l until its third lowercase group, and gets to c first. Zaner-Bloser teaches q sixth; Handwriting Without Tears puts q in the final group of four.


The cursive book is structured differently again. The Grade 2 cursive sample teaches four basic strokes — Undercurve, Downcurve, Overcurve, Diagonal — then all twenty-six lowercase letters in four groups, and only then the capitals in five groups.


Lowercase cursive, in order: i, t, u, w, e, l, b; then h, f, k, r, s, j, p; then a, d, g, o, c, q; then n, m, y, x, v, z.


Uppercase cursive, in order: A, O, D, C, E; then N, M, H, K, U; then Y, Z, V, W, X; then I, J, Q, T, F; then G, S, L, P, R, B.


The publisher also makes later-grade teacher editions available as samples, so the sequence can be followed through the grades without a purchase.


So the same publisher pairs each letter with its capital in manuscript and separates them entirely in cursive. That is not an inconsistency to criticise — the two scripts raise different problems, and joining is the one cursive has — but it does mean that a student moving from the Grade 1 book to the Grade 2 cursive book changes organising principle as well as script.

Logic of English: the groups are named after the strokes


The Rhythm of Handwriting series publishes a cursive sample whose table of contents gives the complete sequence with the group names attached.


Lowercase, all before any uppercase, in four groups:


  • Swing Letters — i, t, u, s, j, p, r, w

  • Curve Letters — a, d, g, qu, c, o

  • Loop Letters — l, b, f, e, h, k

  • Bump Letters — n, m, y, v, x, z


Uppercase follows in five groups: Curve Letters P, B, R, N, M, K, H, U, Y, W, V, X, Z; then Roll Letters A, O, C, E; then Loop Letters G, S; then Circle Letters J, Q; then Slash Letters T, F, D. The book also carries separate sections on letters that connect at the baseline, letters that connect with a dip connector, and uppercase letters that do not connect at all.


Now put this beside the Zaner-Bloser cursive sequence, because the comparison is sharper than any abstract disagreement about method.


Both begin with i, t, u. Both end with the same six letters — n, m, y, x, v, z in one, n, m, y, v, x, z in the other. In between, the second and third groups are effectively swapped and re-membered.


Zaner-Bloser puts e, l, b in its first group and s, j, p, r in its second; Logic of English puts s, j, p, r, w in its first group and l, b, e, h, k in its third. Zaner-Bloser's third group, a, d, g, o, c, q, is almost exactly Logic of English's second, a, d, g, qu, c, o.


And one small difference carries more weight than it looks: Logic of English teaches qu as a single unit, where Zaner-Bloser teaches q on its own. That is a phonics decision showing up inside a handwriting sequence, and it is the only place in this whole comparison where a program's letter order is visibly answering to something other than the hand.


The uppercase sequences diverge further. Zaner-Bloser opens with A, O, D, C, E. Logic of English opens with a thirteen-letter curve group and does not reach A, O, C, E until its third.


Two published cursive programs. Nearly the same first group, nearly the same last group, and two incompatible routes between them. Nothing published adjudicates which route is right.

Getty-Dubay: one alphabet, so the transition mostly disappears


The Getty-Dubay Italic curriculum overview, published alongside the series' own catalogue pages, takes a different position on the question the other three answer with a sequence. It changes the letterforms so that the sequence problem shrinks.


The document's own framing, and it is worth reading carefully:


"With italic handwriting, however, print ('basic italic') and cursive ('cursive italic') are unified. This sequence builds on previously learned concepts; basic italic lowercase letterforms are essentially identical to those of cursive italic."

The claim is specific and checkable. The overview states that only one capital letterform changes in the transition from basic italic to cursive italic: capital Y. It describes joins as "eight specific ways to connect most — but not all — letters," and says that many of those joins are optional for the student.


It is also the only program in this comparison that publishes a numeric specification for slope: "Getty-Dubay Italic recommends a 5º slope for all grades." Zaner-Bloser asks for "uniform vertical slant" in manuscript without a figure. Handwriting Without Tears does not publish a figure on the documents checked here.


The overview argues the case for its own design by citing retention research — Bara and Morin (2013) on students abandoning continuous cursive by fifth grade, a College Board figure that "only 15% of US high school seniors use conventional cursive," and Graham, Berninger and Weintraub (1998) on handwriting style, speed and legibility.


Those are the publisher's citations, reported here as the publisher's citations. The underlying studies were not retrieved for this post, so treat the figures as what the overview states rather than as verified findings.

The stroke vocabularies share no terms


Set the four naming systems side by side and the translation problem becomes the finding.


  • Handwriting Without Tears names groups after the motion or the start: Frog Jump, Starting Corner, Center Starting, Magic c, Diver.

  • Zaner-Bloser names strokes after the curve: Undercurve, Downcurve, Overcurve, Checkstroke, Diagonal.

  • Logic of English names groups after the gesture: Swing, Curve, Loop, Bump, Roll, Circle, Slash.

  • Getty-Dubay works in italic terminology: basic italic, cursive italic, joins, slope, serifs.


Not one term appears in two systems with the same meaning. Zaner-Bloser's Overcurve and Logic of English's Bump describe overlapping motions under unrelated names. Logic of English's Curve Letters and Zaner-Bloser's Downcurve group contain nearly the same letters and are named differently. Getty-Dubay says slope where Zaner-Bloser says slant.


This is the pattern this site has now documented across reading program labels, syllable division rules, decodable text criteria and error correction procedures: a shared vocabulary that is not actually shared. Handwriting is the most granular instance of it yet, because the unit of disagreement is a single pencil stroke.

"Legibility" is one publisher's whole system and is absent from the federal guide


Zaner-Bloser does not treat legibility as a general aspiration. It treats it as the architecture. From the Grade 1 teacher edition, verbatim:


"Shape, Size, Spacing, and Slant — four Keys to Legibility — are the basis of Zaner-Bloser's unique instructional system. The Keys form an assessment rubric for teachers and students. The Keys appear in the Student Edition to help students self-evaluate their handwriting."

The teacher edition prints the self-evaluation questions the Keys become in practice: "Did you write with correct strokes so your letters have good shape?"; "Are your letters the right size?"; "Did you use proper spacing between your letters and words?"; "Does your writing have uniform vertical slant?"


Now the count, taken from the text of the 2012 IES practice guide on elementary writing. The guide is set in two columns, so it was extracted twice in two different reading modes and every count below was run on whitespace-normalised text in both, because a phrase broken across a line or a column returns a false zero to a naive search.


The guide runs to 49,676 words. It uses the word handwriting 62 times. It uses the word legibility zero times in both extractions. The word legible appears once. The phrase letter formation appears twice — once in the recommendation itself and once inside a description of a study. The phrase teaching order appears zero times.


So the construct that organises an entire commercial handwriting curriculum, forms its assessment rubric and appears in its student workbooks for self-evaluation is not a word the federal guide on teaching elementary writing uses at all.


And the phrase scope and sequence appears exactly once — which is a better finding than a zero would have been, because of where it sits. It is not about handwriting. It is in Recommendation 3's section on sentence construction, in this sentence: "One approach is to follow the grammar curriculum's scope and sequence but modify the method of teaching."


The guide knows the phrase. It uses it about grammar. It never uses it about letters.

Four rubrics, and each one scores what its own curriculum teaches


This is the part that changes how a score should be read.


Zaner-Bloser's rubric has four criteria: shape, size, spacing, slant. Getty-Dubay's scope and sequence has students "evaluate his/her own handwriting according to letter shapes, slope, and strokes" and use "correct spacing within words and between words to develop legible handwriting" — so four again, but a different four.


Learning Without Tears sells a separate assessment, The Print Tool. The publisher's own online scoring page refers to "the seven specific handwriting components that The Print Tool evaluates" and does not name them on that page.


A reseller's product listing names them as memory, orientation, placement, size, start, sequence and word spacing. Because the publisher page confirms the count but not the list, the list is reported here as the reseller states it, and a practitioner relying on it for a report should confirm it against the manual.


Lay the three rubrics over each other and the overlap is thin:


  • Spacing is in all three.

  • Size is in Zaner-Bloser and in The Print Tool's seven, but is not in the Getty-Dubay self-evaluation list.

  • Shape is in Zaner-Bloser and Getty-Dubay but is not among The Print Tool's seven components.

  • Slant or slope is in Zaner-Bloser and Getty-Dubay and is not among The Print Tool's seven.

  • Memory, start and sequence are unique to The Print Tool — and they are precisely the three things a letter-group curriculum built on starting points and stroke order is designed to produce.


That last line is the point. The Print Tool scores where the stroke starts and in what order it runs, because its sibling curriculum teaches letters grouped by exactly that. Zaner-Bloser scores slant, because slant is one of its four Keys. Each rubric measures the thing its own program decided mattered.


A legibility score from a program's own rubric is not a measure of legibility in general. It is a measure of conformity to that program's letter model. Two students with identical handwriting can score differently on two rubrics, and neither rubric is wrong.

It is the same structural problem this site has reported for standard scores and referencing frames and for reading program evidence ratings: the number is only interpretable alongside the rule that produced it.

What the federal guide says, and what it declines to say


Teaching Elementary School Students to Be Effective Writers, NCEE 2012-4058, June 2012 and revised October 2018, is the document a practitioner should actually read on this. It is free, it is short, and its full PDF and ERIC record are both open.


Recommendation 3 is "Teach students to become fluent with handwriting, spelling, sentence construction, typing, and word processing," and its first how-to step is "Teach very young writers how to hold a pencil correctly and form letters fluently and efficiently."


What the guide says about forming letters is this, verbatim:


"Teachers also should show young writers the most efficient and legible ways to form each letter, regardless of whether print or cursive script is used."

And then, in the same passage:


"The specific curriculum is less important than teaching fluent, effortless letter formation."

Read those two sentences against the preceding sections. The guide declines to adjudicate print against cursive. It declines to specify a letter order. It declines to name a curriculum. It recommends guided practice "using letters with numbered arrows depicting the order and direction of each stroke" — a method, not a sequence — and notes that such diagrams are freely available.


It also states plainly that "Because handwriting is a motor skill, it works best to practice in multiple short sessions," notes that students "might practice a specific letter only five to eight times before moving to another activity," and recommends practising letters from memory. Those are instructions about distribution and retrieval, not about which letter comes first.

Recommendation 3's evidence base, and a caution about the wording


The guide rates Recommendation 3 as moderate evidence, drawn from nine studies of instruction in handwriting, spelling, sentence construction and word processing. Two details make it unusually relevant to one-to-one and small-group practice, and the guide states both:


  • "Seven of the studies were conducted on populations the panel determined were at risk for writing difficulties, and all but two involved interventions delivered to pairs or small groups of students."

  • "Eight of the nine studies found generally positive effects on outcomes such as spelling, handwriting, sentence structure, the quantity of text produced, and the overall quality of student writing."


Before anyone cites that nine, read the breakdown the guide gives in the same paragraph. Three of the nine tested handwriting instruction, "in which students were taught how to form letters and practiced writing the letters repeatedly in short sessions." Three tested explicit instruction in phonological awareness, spelling phonics, morphological spelling and word study. Two tested sentence-construction interventions. One tested a word processor.


So the moderate rating that gets quoted as federal support for handwriting instruction rests on nine studies of which three were about handwriting. The rating is for the whole recommendation, which covers four skills, and the guide is explicit about that. A vendor citation that compresses it to "nine studies" is reporting the recommendation's evidence base, not handwriting's.


The guide also qualifies its own eight-of-nine figure twice in the same breath: "in some of these studies, positive effects on one outcome were mixed with no effects or negative effects on another," and "In the ninth study, which examined spelling instruction, no effects were found."


A caution that matters if you are going to quote those figures. Recommendation 4 of the same guide is also rated moderate, is also drawn from nine studies, and its evidence paragraph also reports that seven of the nine involved students at risk for writing difficulties and all but two involved instruction provided to pairs or small groups.


The two paragraphs are close enough in wording to be confused by a search, and they are about different recommendations.


If you cite the nine-study base for handwriting, cite it from the Recommendation 3 section and check the surrounding sentence. This post's figures come from the Recommendation 3 evidence paragraph, which names handwriting, spelling, sentence construction and word processing as the domains.


The guide then records what it cannot support, and this is the most useful sentence in the section for anyone working one to one:


"The panel believes it is critical that teachers carefully match instruction in these skills to areas of student need. The panel cannot confirm that whole-class instruction without regard to varying student abilities will produce effects of the same magnitude."

That is a federal panel saying, in its own voice, that it cannot vouch for undifferentiated whole-class delivery of these skills. It lines up exactly with the strongest moderator in the research literature, which is in the next section.

The one commercial handwriting program the guide names, and why


Across 49,676 words, the guide names no handwriting curriculum in any recommendation. Handwriting Without Tears appears zero times. D'Nealian, Palmer, Getty and Size Matters appear zero times.


Zaner-Bloser appears twice, and both mentions are in the panel's own conflict-of-interest disclosure. The guide states that its lead author "receives royalties as an author of SRA/McGraw-Hill Imagine It, a reading/writing program," and of "Zaner-Bloser Spell It Write, a spelling program," and that "He also is a consulting author on Zaner-Bloser Handwriting, a handwriting program for students in kindergarten through 8th grade."


This should be read the right way round. The disclosure is printed in the guide itself, in the guide's own front matter, which is the system working rather than failing. And the recommendation that follows is the one quoted above: the specific curriculum is less important than the outcome. A panel whose lead author consults on a handwriting program produced a recommendation that advantages no handwriting program.


It is still worth a practitioner knowing, for two reasons. The lead author of this guide is also the lead author of the meta-analysis the whole field cites on handwriting instruction. And a vendor claim that cites federal guidance is citing a document that names no vendor at all.

What the research attaches to, and the boundary on it


The best single evidence document on handwriting instruction as a category is Santangelo and Graham's comprehensive meta-analysis, Educational Psychology Review 28(2), 225–265, 2016, also in ERIC, summarised in an open institutional record and listed in Reading Rockets' research library. Its figures, re-verified for this post:


  • Handwriting instruction against no instruction or non-handwriting instruction: legibility ES 0.59, fluency ES 0.63.

  • Downstream writing outcomes: quality ES 0.84, length ES 1.33, fluency ES 0.48.

  • Motor instruction: legibility ES 0.10, fluency ES −0.07.

  • Individualising the instruction: legibility ES 0.69.

  • Delivering it via technology: legibility ES 0.85.


Every one of those effects attaches to a practice, not to a brand. Not one of the five programs compared above appears as a moderator. There is no published effect size for Handwriting Without Tears against Zaner-Bloser, or for either against italic, and this post is not asserting one.


The boundary matters, so here it is explicitly. These figures do not say that any named program is effective or ineffective. They say that teaching letter formation beats not teaching it, that individualising and technology-assisted delivery moderate the legibility effect upward, and that isolated motor work does not.


On the last of those, the full treatment with three independent sources is in the dysgraphia and writing intervention post, and that section is not repeated here.

The dosage question, and a correction to our own earlier post


This site reported in September that writing publishers mostly do not publish a dose, and named Zaner-Bloser's "just 15 minutes per day" and Expressive Writing's lesson count as the exceptions among the programs surveyed then. The Zaner-Bloser figure is still on its page, checked today.


That survey missed one, and the correction belongs in print. Getty-Dubay publishes a full grade-by-grade dose in its curriculum overview's Scope and Sequence, stated in minutes per week: 25 to 50 at kindergarten, 30 to 100 at first grade, 45 to 100 at second, 60 to 120 at third, fourth and fifth, and 40 at sixth. Its stated program goal is "To write neat, legible handwriting with automaticity and without prompts."


That is the most complete published dose of any handwriting program in either survey, and it comes from the vendor rather than from a third-party chart. The earlier post's general finding stands — most writing publishers do not publish a dose — but the list of exceptions was short by one, and Getty-Dubay's is the fullest of them.


For the programs above, what is still not published anywhere we could find: a lesson count for Handwriting Without Tears, Zaner-Bloser or Logic of English; a session length or weekly frequency for Handwriting Without Tears or Logic of English; and a group size for any of the four.


If you need to check a program against the forty minutes a week a student actually has with you, three of the four will not let you.

The print-to-cursive question nobody adjudicates


It is worth isolating, because it is the question practitioners get asked and the published record is thinnest on it.


Zaner-Bloser teaches manuscript in Grades K to 2 and cursive from Grade 2 onward, with different letterforms and a different organising principle for each. Handwriting Without Tears publishes separate print and cursive sequences. Getty-Dubay's entire design argument is that the transition is the problem and a unified letterform removes it. Logic of English publishes both a print and a cursive volume.


The federal guide's position is the sentence quoted earlier: the most efficient and legible ways to form each letter, "regardless of whether print or cursive script is used." That is the guide declining to take a side.


The guide uses the word cursive three times in 49,676 words and the word manuscript twice. There is no recommendation on the question in any of the four recommendations. So the honest answer to "should this student be taught cursive" is that the document a practitioner would normally reach for does not answer it, and the programs answer it in four different ways, each consistent with its own design.


What this does not mean is that the question is unanswerable or unimportant. It means there is no published consensus to cite, and a practitioner who presents a cursive decision as evidence-based should be able to say which evidence.

Who certifies, and who accredits


Briefly, because this ground is covered in detail elsewhere on the site and the finding has not changed.


The Learning Without Tears certification route is the vendor's own, and the scoring tool for its assessment is gated behind it: the publisher's page describes Print Tool Online Scoring as "an easy-to-use tool for Level 1 certified handwriting specialists." So the instrument, the curriculum it maps to, the training and the scoring platform all come from one organisation.


Both of the large publishers also make evidence claims against the federal ESSA tier framework, and the tiers describe what kind of study exists rather than ranking quality. Checked on 11 November 2026, the two claims are not the same shape. The Handwriting Without Tears program page states that the approach "meets ESSA's Tier 2 evidence criteria."


The Zaner-Bloser handwriting page refers to "ESSA-Level criteria for effectiveness" and to "ESSA Level Evidence Badges" awarded in December 2023, January 2024 and March 2024, attributes the analysis to a named research firm, and routes the reader to a downloadable paper rather than naming a numeric level in its page text.


One named tier against one unnamed level, both described as ESSA evidence. If you are comparing the two claims, you are comparing a specific criterion with a badge.


That is not an accusation. It is a description of a market with no external accreditor. The full treatment — including what the certification requires, and the finding that no body accredits handwriting or written-expression training as a category while three bodies accredit structured literacy training — is in the dysgraphia and writing intervention post, and the broader credentialing landscape is in what learning specialist certification actually exists.


For how this sits against the other roles that claim writing instruction, the role comparison is the hub, and the referral boundaries with SLPs and OTs are set out separately.

A decision sequence, not a decision


This post will not tell you which program to use, and no document cited here will either. What the published record does support is an order of questions.


  1. Decide whether the problem is transcription at all. The instruments that answer that, and what each one scores, are compared in written expression assessment tools.

  2. Check which program the student is already on at school. If there is one, a second letter order taught in your sessions is a cost with no published benefit. This is the single most practical consequence of everything above.

  3. If you are choosing, read the sequence before the brochure. All four programs above publish theirs free. The sequence tells you what the student will actually be asked to do; the evidence page does not.

  4. Match the rubric to the sequence you chose. A legibility rubric from a different program's family will score the student against a letter model they were not taught.

  5. Check the dose against the time you have. One of the four publishes a grade-by-grade weekly figure. For the others, you are estimating, and you should say so in your notes.

  6. Attach your plan to the practice, not the brand. The effects in the meta-analysis belong to individualised, distributed, explicit letter-formation instruction with practice from memory. Every program above can deliver that or fail to.


If you are writing this into a plan, the treatment plan post covers the mechanics and session notes and progress reports covers the documentation.

Where the published record runs out


The gaps are as useful as the findings, and this post would be overstating itself without them.


  • No published standard specifies a letter order. The 2012 IES guide does not. The phrase teaching order appears nowhere in it, and its single use of scope and sequence is about a grammar curriculum. Whether some other body publishes an order was not established here; the claim is about this guide.

  • No head-to-head study. No published comparison of these programs against each other was located, and none of them appears as a moderator in the meta-analysis. If one exists, it is not in the sources checked.

  • The Print Tool's seven components are confirmed by count but not by list on the publisher's page. The list above comes from a reseller.

  • Getty-Dubay's research citations were not independently retrieved. The Bara and Morin, College Board and Graham, Berninger and Weintraub figures are reported as the overview's own citations.

  • Lesson counts, session lengths and group sizes are unpublished for most of these programs, as set out above.

  • The within-group letter order for one Handwriting Without Tears capital group differs between two of the publisher's own documents. The membership agrees; the order does not.

  • Logic of English's print sequence was not examined here — only the cursive volume's, which is what the free sample covers. The print order may differ from the cursive order, as Zaner-Bloser's does.

  • No claim is made about any program's effectiveness, and none of the sources above supports one.

Frequently asked questions


Does it matter which order the letters are taught in?


No published standard says it does, and the federal guide says the specific curriculum is less important than fluent, effortless letter formation. What does matter, practically, is consistency: a student taught two different orders by two different adults is carrying a cost that nothing in the published record offsets.


Which handwriting program has the best evidence?


None of the four compared here has a published effect size against any other, and none appears as a moderator in Santangelo and Graham's meta-analysis. The evidence in this area attaches to practices — explicit instruction in letter formation, individualised delivery, short distributed practice, writing letters from memory — rather than to brands.


Should a student be taught print or cursive?


The 2012 IES guide declines to take a side, asking for the most efficient and legible way to form each letter "regardless of whether print or cursive script is used." It uses the word cursive three times in nearly fifty thousand words and makes no recommendation on the question. The four programs answer it in four different ways.


What are the four Keys to Legibility?


Shape, size, spacing and slant. They are Zaner-Bloser's, they form that program's assessment rubric and appear in its student workbooks for self-evaluation, and they are not a field-wide standard. The word legibility does not appear in the 2012 IES guide at all.


Can I use a program's own legibility rubric as a progress measure?


You can use it as a measure of conformity to that program's letter model, which is a real and useful thing. What it is not is a general measure of legibility, and it will not be comparable to a score from another program's rubric. The three rubrics compared above share only one criterion.


Does Handwriting Without Tears teach capitals or lowercase first?


Capitals, in three groups organised by starting point, before any lowercase letter. That is the opposite structure from Zaner-Bloser's Grade 1 book, which introduces each lowercase letter together with its capital.

Keep the practitioner-facing work coming


This is the kind of comparison that only exists if someone sits down with four teacher editions and counts. If that is useful to your practice, join the educator list and the next one comes to you.

Recent Posts

See All

Comments


bottom of page