Dyslexia Definition Compared: Five Bodies, Five Answers
You have written the word "dyslexia" in a report, a treatment plan or an intake summary, and you have probably never had to say which definition you meant.
There are at least five published ones, they disagree with each other on points that change what you write, and if you set out to find a dyslexia definition to compare against the others you will discover something nobody announced loudly: two of the five were replaced inside the last year.
The one most of the field still quotes was retired on 22 October 2025.
That is not a technicality. It is the definition written into most state dyslexia legislation and guidance, it is the one on the wall of a lot of training programs, and its own issuing body has now published something different. If you are a practitioner who has to put a sentence in writing about a student, the gap between those two facts is yours to manage.
This post does one thing. It sets the five published definitions side by side, says who issued each and when, and marks the places where they actually conflict. Every definition below is quoted from the body that published it.
Five bodies, five definitions, and no mechanism anywhere that requires them to agree.
What the International Dyslexia Association published in 2025
The IDA Board of Directors adopted a new definition on 22 October 2025. IDA publishes it in full, and it reads:
"Dyslexia is a specific learning disability characterized by difficulties in word reading and/or spelling that involve accuracy, speed, or both and vary depending on the orthography. These difficulties occur along a continuum of severity and persist even with instruction that is effective for the individual's peers. The causes of dyslexia are complex and involve combinations of genetic, neurobiological, and environmental influences that interact throughout development. Underlying difficulties with phonological and morphological processing are common but not universal, and early oral language weaknesses often foreshadow literacy challenges."
It continues into consequences:
"Secondary consequences include reading comprehension problems and reduced reading and writing experience that can impede growth in language, knowledge, written expression, and overall academic achievement. Psychological well-being and employment opportunities also may be affected. Although identification and targeted instruction are important at any age, language and literacy support before and during the early years of education is particularly effective."
Read it once for what is new rather than for what is familiar. Four things in it were not in the definition it replaced.
Orthography is now in the text. Difficulties "vary depending on the orthography" — meaning the same underlying profile shows up differently in a shallow orthography than in English. That is a direct concession that the old definition was written from English outward.
Phonology is no longer the mechanism. The new wording says phonological and morphological difficulties are "common but not universal." The old wording said the difficulties "typically result from a deficit in the phonological component of language."
Morphology appears for the first time. It sits alongside phonology rather than under it.
Severity is a continuum. The word "continuum" is in the definition itself, not in a commentary on it.
The 2002 definition, which is the one you have memorised
The definition it replaced was adopted by the same board on 12 November 2002, and the IDA keeps the consensus project page live as a historical reference. It reads:
"Dyslexia is characterized by difficulties with accurate and / or fluent word recognition and by poor spelling and decoding abilities. These difficulties typically result from a deficit in the phonological component of language that is often unexpected in relation to other cognitive abilities and the provision of effective classroom instruction. Secondary consequences may include problems in reading comprehension and reduced reading experience that can impede growth of vocabulary and background knowledge."
The provenance matters more than it usually would. That text came out of a consensus group reconvened by G. Emerson Dickman with sponsorship from the National Institute of Child Health and Human Development and the IDA, and it was written to update an IDA definition from 1994.
So the 2025 text is the third in a line, not a break with tradition. An IDA branch copy of the 2002 text is still circulating as a one-page handout, which is part of why it stayed in use.
Notice what the 2002 wording does that the 2025 wording does not. It says the difficulty is "often unexpected in relation to other cognitive abilities." That clause is the reason a generation of reports contain a cognitive profile, and it is the clause the revision argued hardest about.
Why the 2002 wording was revised, in the researchers' own words
The case for revision was made in print before the board acted. Catts and colleagues published "Revisiting the Definition of Dyslexia" in Annals of Dyslexia in 2024, and it is worth reading in full if you supervise anyone. Their complaints were specific.
The revision itself was then written up as Defining Dyslexia: 2025 Revision, which the IDA points to from its own definition page as the account of the new text's scientific basis; the publisher's record for that paper is the other place to find it. The surrounding argument continued in the same journal, including Thoughts on the Definition of Dyslexia.
On the phonological clause, they preferred "difficulty in phonological processing," arguing that the 2002 wording implies "a more general disorder in phonology" than the evidence supports.
On unexpectedness, they called it "particularly problematic" that the definition implies a relationship between phonological difficulty and effective instruction. Their position is that the reading difficulties, not the phonological ones, are what should be unexpected given effective instruction.
On intelligence, they noted that the "other cognitive abilities" reference has led to reliance on the "now debunked IQ-achievement discrepancy."
On equity, they observed that the definition "makes no mention of race, linguistic diversity, or poverty."
The clause that produced a generation of discrepancy-based reports was removed because the discrepancy it implied does not hold up.
And on reach, they state plainly that "most states in the US have adopted the definition in their dyslexia legislation or guidelines." The IDA's own page says the same thing in gentler terms, describing the 2002 text as now incorporated into many state laws.
That is the structural problem in one sentence. A definition can be revised by the body that wrote it far faster than it can be revised everywhere it was copied.
Nothing here is legal advice. This post reports what bodies and agencies have published about the word, and nothing more than that. It does not tell you what any statute, regulation or school district requires of you.
The question of what a particular state's dyslexia law obliges anyone to do belongs with an attorney licensed there and with the state education agency, not with a blog post. If you work in schools, the same caution applies to eligibility: what follows describes published category language, and published category language is not entitlement.
The DSM has no dyslexia diagnosis
This surprises people who assume the diagnostic manual is the authority of last resort. It is not, because it does not define the word.
The American Psychiatric Association's own public explainer on specific learning disorder describes one diagnosis covering reading, mathematics and written expression, with specifiers identifying which area is affected. The reading specifier is "with impairment in reading." Dyslexia appears beside it in parentheses, and the APA describes it as an alternative term: "Dyslexia may be used as an alternative term that refers to problems with word reading fluency."
So in DSM terms, dyslexia is not a diagnosis, a subtype or a severity level. It is a word you may use for part of a specifier. Severity in DSM is rated mild, moderate or severe, and it is rated on the disorder, not on the word.
If a report crosses your desk carrying a DSM code and the word dyslexia in the narrative, those are two different claims from two different systems, and only one of them is a diagnosis. The same discipline applies to reading any evaluation that lands in your file, which is a longer subject covered in what you may and may not do with a psychoeducational report.
The federal category names dyslexia once and defines it never
The federal regulation that practitioners reach for is the specific learning disability definition at 34 CFR 300.8(c)(10). The regulation text defines specific learning disability as a disorder in one or more of the basic psychological processes involved in understanding or using language, and then lists conditions the term includes: perceptual disabilities, brain injury, minimal brain dysfunction, dyslexia and developmental aphasia.
That is the whole of it. The word appears once, in a list, inside the definition of a different term.
The regulation then excludes learning problems primarily resulting from visual, hearing or motor disabilities, intellectual disability, emotional disturbance, or environmental, cultural or economic disadvantage.
Dyslexia appears in the federal regulation exactly once, as one item in a list of conditions included in a broader category. There is no federal definition of dyslexia.
Practitioners sometimes describe the federal record as silent on dyslexia. It is not silent. It is thin, and thin in a specific way: it establishes that the word names something inside the category, and it leaves the content of the word to somebody else.
Britain answered the question with a panel, not a sentence
The second definition to change in the last year did not come from a board vote. It came from a Delphi study.
Carroll, Holden, Kirby, Thompson and Snowling, with the Dyslexia Delphi Panel, published "Toward a consensus on dyslexia" in the Journal of Child Psychology and Psychiatry in 2025, accepted in November 2024.
The method matters as much as the result. Seventy-one experts accepted places on the panel, with 58 responding in the first round and 57 in the second; agreement was set at 80 percent; two survey rounds were followed by a discussion of three borderline statements. Forty-two statements were accepted.
The result is not one sentence. It is a set, and these are the load-bearing ones:
"Dyslexia is a set of processing difficulties that affect the acquisition of reading and spelling."
"In dyslexia, some or all aspects of literacy attainment are weak in relation to age, standard teaching and instruction, and level of other attainments."
"Across languages and age groups, difficulties in reading fluency and spelling are a key marker of dyslexia."
"Dyslexic difficulties exist on a continuum and can be experienced to various degrees of severity."
"The nature and developmental trajectory of dyslexia depend on multiple genetic and environmental influences."
"Dyslexia frequently co-occurs with one or more other developmental difficulties, including developmental language disorder, dyscalculia, ADHD, and developmental coordination disorder."
On phonology the panel landed almost exactly where the IDA landed, and the wording is careful: the most commonly observed cognitive impairment is a difficulty in phonological processing, "However, phonological difficulties do not fully explain the variability that is observed."
The panel also said what it thought was wrong with the manuals. Its discussion holds that ICD-11 and DSM-5 emphasise specificity in a way that conflicts with research showing frequent co-occurrence, and that neither addresses causes. That is a characterisation by the panel, reported here as theirs; this post has not independently read the ICD-11 entry and does not quote it.
The British Dyslexia Association was represented on the panel, with Chivonne Preston named on the panel list. The paper does not describe that as an organisational endorsement, and it would be wrong to report it as one.
What the BDA publishes now
The BDA's current downloadable dyslexia factsheet, versioned V26.1, describes dyslexia as a lifelong, genetic, neurological specific learning difficulty that mainly affects accurate and fluent word reading and spelling, and it points readers to the Delphi definition for the full text rather than reproducing a formal definition of its own.
That factsheet carries no date, only a version marker. It is a current publication and the version string is the only provenance on its face, so if the date is load-bearing for something you are writing, go to the BDA directly rather than relying on a version number.
It is worth being clear that the British usage of the word has always been broader than the American one, which is a point already made at length in the discussion of what a screener can and cannot tell you — see the same word means something different in Britain. The Delphi definition narrows the distance considerably. It does not close it.
Where the five definitions actually conflict
Set them side by side and the disagreements are not stylistic. Five of them change what you would write.
Is phonology the cause or a correlate?
IDA 2002 said the difficulties "typically result from" a phonological deficit. IDA 2025 says phonological and morphological difficulties are "common but not universal." The Delphi panel says phonological difficulties "do not fully explain the variability."
The DSM specifier does not name a mechanism at all. If your report template contains a sentence attributing a student's decoding difficulty to a phonological deficit as a matter of definition, that sentence is now out of step with every current definition in this list.
Is unexpectedness part of the concept?
IDA 2002 built it in through "other cognitive abilities." IDA 2025 removed the cognitive comparison and kept an instructional one: difficulties "persist even with instruction that is effective for the individual's peers." The Delphi statements keep a comparison to "level of other attainments," which is attainment rather than cognition. These are three different comparisons, and only one of them invites a cognitive profile.
Is co-occurrence expected or disqualifying?
The Delphi panel puts co-occurrence in the definition. The federal regulation's exclusion clause works in the other direction, ruling out learning problems primarily resulting from other listed conditions. Those are answers to different questions, but they are read in the same room.
Does the language the student reads matter?
IDA 2025 and the Delphi statements both say yes, explicitly, across orthographies and languages. IDA 2002 did not mention it. This is the difference that bites hardest in practice when you assess a student whose first language is not English, and the norm-sample problem that sits underneath it is a separate subject in whose norms are these.
Is dyslexia a word or a diagnosis?
IDA calls it a specific learning disability. DSM makes it an alternative term for part of a specifier. The federal regulation makes it one item in a list. The Delphi panel calls it "a set of processing difficulties." These are four different grammatical objects.
What this changes about your writing, concretely
The honest answer is that no definition tells you what to do with a student, and none of them is trying to. What they change is what you can defend in writing.
Four habits follow, and none of them requires you to pick a winner.
Name the definition you are using
"Dyslexia, as defined by the IDA in its 2025 revision" is nine extra words and it removes every ambiguity above. A report that uses the word bare is making a claim it has not specified.
Date the definition you quote
If you quote the 2002 text — and there are legitimate reasons to, including that it is the text a given state's guidance adopted — say that it is the 2002 text. The IDA has published a replacement, and a reader in 2027 will want to know which one you meant.
Stop writing the mechanism into the description
None of the three current definitions lets you assert a phonological cause as definitional. You can report a student's phonological processing scores, which is a measurement, and the construct boundaries there are their own problem — see where the construct ends.
Keep the identification question where it belongs
Nothing in any of these definitions authorises you to identify a condition. The scope boundaries around that are set by your professional body rather than by a definition, and for educational therapists specifically they are mapped in the practitioner scope map and in the role comparison between educational therapists, learning specialists and executive function coaches.
A definition tells you what a word means. It does not tell you that you are permitted to apply it.
The pattern this is the fourth example of
If you have read much of this site you will recognise the shape. A word that practitioners use as though it were specified turns out to be specified by several bodies at once, in incompatible terms, with no coordinating mechanism.
It happened with the label on a training program, where the Academy's position is that Orton-Gillingham is not a program at all and eleven publishers make no two claims alike. It happened with what "aligned" to the IDA standards actually means. It happened with the umbrella phrase itself, in what "the science of reading" actually names. And it happens here, with the field's central term.
The useful conclusion is not cynical. It is that naming your source is cheap, and that the practitioners who do it are the ones whose reports survive being read closely two years later. The same logic applies to the numbers you quote: see what actually makes a score too old and what that confidence band around a score means.
Where the published record runs out
Several things in this area are genuinely not available, and it is worth saying which.
The ICD-11 entry was not read for this post. The WHO browser was not retrieved from a primary source this run, so the only account of ICD-11 here is the Delphi panel's characterisation of it, attributed to them. If an ICD-11 code is load-bearing in something you are writing, read the entry yourself in WHO's own browser rather than taking it from this post or from the panel's summary.
No state's dyslexia statute or guidance was read for this post. The claim that most states adopted the 2002 definition is Catts and colleagues' claim, in a peer-reviewed paper, and the IDA's own page makes a similar statement. Neither is a survey you can cite for a particular state. Which definition your state's guidance uses, and what it requires, is a question for that state's education agency.
The BDA factsheet carries no date. Only a version string.
Nobody publishes a crosswalk. There is no document anywhere in this list that maps the five definitions onto each other, says which governs in which setting, or tells a practitioner which to cite. That absence is the reason this post exists, and it is also the reason to be sceptical of any source that presents one definition as the definition.
No publisher's test manual was read for this post. What the assessment manuals assume about the construct is a real question and a separate one; the instruments themselves are compared in what each spelling measure can diagnose and in the screener comparison linked above.
Frequently asked questions
Which definition of dyslexia should I use in a report?
Name whichever one you are using and date it. If you are writing in a setting governed by state guidance, that guidance may have adopted specific wording, and your state education agency is the authority on which. If you are in private practice and choosing freely, the IDA's 2025 revision is the current text from the body that issued the one most people quote.
Did the IDA definition really change?
Yes. The IDA Board of Directors adopted a new definition on 22 October 2025, and the IDA publishes it alongside a note that the 2002 consensus project page remains available as a historical reference.
Is dyslexia a DSM diagnosis?
No. DSM has one diagnosis, specific learning disorder, with a specifier "with impairment in reading." The APA describes dyslexia as an alternative term referring to problems with word reading fluency.
Does federal regulation define dyslexia?
No. The word appears once in 34 CFR 300.8(c)(10), as one item in the list of conditions included in the definition of specific learning disability. The regulation defines that category, not the word.
Why does the new IDA definition mention orthography?
Because the difficulties present differently depending on the writing system. The 2025 text says they "vary depending on the orthography," which is an explicit acknowledgement that the older wording was framed around English.
Is the phonological deficit account wrong now?
Not wrong, demoted. Every current definition in this list treats phonological difficulty as the most commonly observed cognitive impairment while declining to treat it as the whole explanation. The Delphi panel's wording is that phonological difficulties "do not fully explain the variability that is observed."
Join the Illuminate educator network
If you work with students who struggle to read, you are going to have to write this word down again this week. We publish source-checked explainers for educational therapists, learning specialists and executive function coaches, with every requirement attributed to the body that issued it.
Join the Illuminate educator list and new posts arrive as they publish.




Comments